Blog
What Plumbers Know About Leadership That Most Managers Don't
Related Reading: Check out our comprehensive ABCs of Supervising guide and explore more insights on workplace training.
Three months ago, my kitchen tap started leaking at 2 AM on a Sunday. By Monday morning, I'd called every plumber in Perth, and Jake from Reliable Plumbing showed up at my door looking like he'd rather be anywhere else. What happened next changed how I think about leadership forever.
Jake didn't just fix my tap. He diagnosed a problem I didn't even know existed, explained it without making me feel stupid, delegated tasks to his apprentice seamlessly, and left my kitchen cleaner than he found it. Meanwhile, I'd just spent six months watching a $200,000-a-year executive struggle to manage a team of five people.
That's when it hit me: tradies understand leadership fundamentals that half the MBA graduates I've worked with completely miss.
The "Fix It Right" Mentality
Plumbers can't afford to bodge a job. Water doesn't care about your quarterly targets or stakeholder expectations. It either flows properly or it doesn't. This creates a mindset that most corporate leaders desperately need.
When Jake's apprentice suggested a quick fix that would save twenty minutes, Jake shut it down immediately. "We do it properly, or we don't do it at all," he said. No committee meetings. No risk assessments. Just clear standards and immediate accountability.
Compare that to the average workplace where "good enough" solutions multiply like rabbits. We patch systems instead of fixing them. We hire consultants to study problems we already know the answers to. We create workarounds that become permanent features.
I've seen million-dollar projects fail because nobody wanted to admit the foundation was wrong. A plumber would have called it out on day one.
The Apprenticeship Advantage
Here's something that'll ruffle feathers: traditional apprenticeship programs produce better leaders than most university business courses. There, I said it.
Watch a master tradie work with an apprentice. The learning is immediate, practical, and consequence-driven. Mistakes have real costs. Success means actual skill development, not just theoretical knowledge.
The apprentice doesn't just observe. They get their hands dirty from week one, starting with simple tasks and gradually taking on more complex work. The master provides guidance but expects independence. Compare that to graduate programs where high-potential employees spend months in meetings about meetings.
Telstra's technical training programs get this right. Their field technicians develop genuine problem-solving skills because they can't Google their way out of a cable fault at the top of a power pole.
But most corporate "mentoring" programs? They're coffee catch-ups disguised as professional development.
Clear Communication Under Pressure
Ever notice how tradies explain complex problems in simple terms? They have to. Their customers aren't engineers.
When my hot water system died last winter, the technician didn't bamboozle me with technical jargon. He showed me the faulty component, explained why it failed, outlined my options, and gave me honest advice about costs versus benefits. Five minutes. Clear. Decisive.
Now think about the last time you sat through a corporate presentation. Probably involved seventeen slides, six acronyms nobody understood, and a recommendation that required three more meetings to finalise.
Jake's leadership skills for supervisors would put most executives to shame. He assesses situations quickly, communicates clearly, and makes decisions based on evidence rather than politics.
The trades industry can't afford communication breakdowns. When you're working with electricity, gas, or structural loads, misunderstandings kill people. That creates a culture of direct, honest conversation that corporate Australia could learn from.
Resource Management Reality
Plumbers understand resource constraints in ways that would terrify most managers. They carry exactly what they need, no more, no less. Their van is organised. Their time is scheduled efficiently. Waste equals lost profit.
I've watched Jake coordinate three different jobs in one morning, managing materials, timing, and customer expectations simultaneously. No project management software. No daily standups. Just practical intelligence and years of experience.
Meanwhile, I've worked with teams that need a two-hour meeting to decide on lunch catering.
The difference? Plumbers face immediate consequences for poor resource management. Corporate managers often get promoted despite it.
The Continuous Learning Imperative
Technology changes constantly in the trades. New materials, updated regulations, different techniques. Plumbers either adapt or go out of business.
Jake mentioned he'd just completed certification for a new type of hot water system. Not because his company mandated it, but because customers were asking for it. That's market-driven professional development.
Contrast that with corporate training programs that everyone complains about but nobody can cancel. When did you last hear someone say, "I can't wait for the next compliance workshop"?
The construction industry figured out skills-based learning decades ago. You learn what you need when you need it, not according to some arbitrary schedule designed by people who've never done the job.
Quality Control That Actually Works
Here's a radical idea: what if managers had to personally guarantee their work like licensed tradespeople do?
When Jake installs a hot water system, his reputation and livelihood depend on it working properly. He can't pass the blame to another department or claim the specifications were unclear.
That accountability creates a quality mindset that permeates everything. Tools are maintained properly. Work is checked before completion. Standards aren't negotiable.
I once worked with a software company where the developers never used their own product. The marketing team had never spoken to a customer. The customer service team couldn't access the systems they were supposed to support.
A plumber who didn't test their own work would be out of business within weeks.
Practical Problem-Solving
Academic business theory loves complex frameworks. Six Sigma. Lean methodology. Design thinking. All valuable tools in the right context, but sometimes you just need to fix the bloody leak.
Tradespeople develop intuitive problem-solving skills through repetition and consequence. They see patterns. They know which solutions work in practice versus on paper. They understand that perfect is often the enemy of good enough.
When my neighbour's bathroom renovation hit unexpected complications, the builder didn't convene a steering committee. He assessed the situation, identified options, explained the trade-offs, and implemented a solution. Total time: forty-five minutes.
Last month, I watched a corporate team spend three weeks analysing whether to upgrade their printer.
The Customer Reality Check
Plumbers face customers directly. They can't hide behind brand messaging or customer service scripts. If the job isn't done properly, they hear about it immediately.
This creates honest feedback loops that most corporate environments lack. Middle management often insulates senior leaders from customer reality, creating delusions about performance and satisfaction.
Jake told me about a job where the customer complained about his pricing. Instead of getting defensive, he walked them through exactly what the work involved, showed them alternative options, and explained why quality costs more upfront but saves money long-term.
The customer paid willingly and referred two neighbours.
Try getting that kind of direct market validation in a corporate role.
Leading Without Authority
Here's something most business schools don't teach: effective leadership often happens without formal authority.
When Jake arrives at a job site with other trades, nobody appointed him project coordinator. But his experience, competence, and communication skills naturally put him in charge of coordinating work sequences and solving problems.
He leads through expertise and reliability, not position or politics. Other tradies listen to him because he knows what he's talking about and gets things done.
Compare that to appointed team leaders who struggle to get basic cooperation from their direct reports.
The Honest Day's Work Philosophy
Maybe this sounds old-fashioned, but there's something refreshing about people who take pride in doing good work regardless of who's watching.
Tradespeople understand the connection between effort and results in ways that knowledge workers often lose sight of. They can point to something concrete they built, fixed, or improved. Their work has tangible impact.
That creates a different relationship with quality and responsibility. It's harder to phone it in when your work is literally visible to everyone.
Where Corporate Leaders Get It Wrong
The biggest mistake business leaders make is thinking complexity equals sophistication. They create elaborate processes for simple problems and wonder why nothing gets done efficiently.
Tradespeople strip problems down to essentials. What needs to happen? What's preventing it? What's the simplest effective solution?
They don't need consensus to make decisions. They don't require approval for obvious improvements. They take ownership of outcomes rather than managing perceptions.
Most importantly, they measure success by results, not activity.
Making the Connection
I'm not suggesting every CEO should start wearing high-vis vests and carrying toolboxes. But there's genuine wisdom in how skilled tradespeople approach leadership challenges.
Start with standards that matter and enforce them consistently. Develop people through real work, not theoretical exercises. Communicate clearly and directly. Take personal responsibility for outcomes. Focus on solving problems rather than appearing sophisticated.
The next time you're frustrated with workplace dysfunction, ask yourself: what would a good plumber do?
Probably something simple, effective, and honest.
And it would probably work.
Further Reading: